Farmland Conservation Easements: How They Work and What Landowners Should Weigh

· Forever Investments

For families who want their farmland to stay farmland, a conservation easement can be a powerful tool. It can also be permanent, complex and difficult to undo. This guide from Forever Investments explains how agricultural conservation easements work, what they can mean for value, taxes and estate planning, and the questions owners should ask before signing.

What a conservation easement is

A conservation easement is a voluntary legal agreement between a landowner and a qualified organization, such as a land trust or a government agency, that permanently limits certain uses of the land to protect its conservation value. For farmland, an agricultural conservation easement typically restricts subdivision and non-agricultural development while allowing the land to keep being farmed.

The owner keeps the land. They can still live on it, farm it, lease it, sell it or leave it to heirs. What changes is that the development rights given up in the easement go with the land forever, binding future owners too.

How easements are created

  • Donated easements: the owner donates the easement and may claim a charitable deduction if federal tax requirements are met.
  • Purchased easements: a program pays the owner for the development rights. At the federal level, the USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service's Agricultural Conservation Easement Program helps fund agricultural land easements through eligible entities, and many states and counties have their own programs. In Florida, the Rural and Family Lands Protection Program, run by the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services, purchases agricultural easements.
  • Bargain sales: part purchase and part donation.

Effect on value

An easement usually reduces the market value of the land, because the right to develop it has been removed. The value of the easement is generally measured by a qualified appraisal as the difference between the land's value before and after the restrictions. Land with little development pressure may see a smaller change; land near growing towns may see a larger one. After the easement, the property is typically valued as working agricultural land.

Tax considerations

  • Income tax: a qualifying donated easement may be deductible as a charitable contribution, subject to federal rules, limits and strict appraisal and documentation requirements.
  • Estate tax: lower land value can reduce the taxable value of an estate, and federal law includes a specific exclusion for some land subject to qualified conservation easements.
  • Property tax: treatment depends on state and local rules and on existing agricultural classification.
  • Proceeds from a sale of development rights are generally taxable; how they are taxed depends on the facts.

The IRS has scrutinized abusive conservation easement transactions, especially syndicated deals promising deductions far above the investment. Legitimate easements on working farmland are a different matter, but they still require careful compliance. Work with an independent tax advisor and attorney.

Effect on estate and succession planning

Because an easement can reduce the land's value and keep it in agriculture, some families use easements as part of a plan to pass land to the next generation without a forced sale. Easement proceeds can also help one heir buy out others. Our article on farmland and generational wealth discusses these long-term goals.

Questions to ask before granting an easement

  1. Which activities will be allowed: new barns, housing for family or workers, solar, timber, processing or agritourism?
  2. Can the land be divided among heirs, and how many building sites are reserved?
  3. Who holds the easement, and how will it be monitored and enforced?
  4. Are there stewardship fees or requirements for a conservation plan?
  5. How will the easement affect financing and the ability to sell?
  6. How do the restrictions fit the farm's likely future, not just its current use?

Easements and investment decisions

For investors, land already under an easement can sometimes be bought at a lower price that reflects its agricultural value. That can improve the income yield, but it also limits future appreciation from development. Weigh it against the other factors described in Farm Income Fund's guide to farmland investment risks, and confirm all easement terms during due diligence.

Common questions

Can a conservation easement be removed later?

Generally no. Most agricultural conservation easements are perpetual, and removing or significantly changing them is rare and difficult. Treat the decision as permanent.

Do I have to allow public access?

Usually not. Most agricultural easements do not require public access, but the holder will have the right to inspect the property for compliance. Check the specific terms.

Can I still sell land with an easement?

Yes. The land can be sold or inherited, and the easement restrictions continue to apply to the new owner.

A long-term perspective

Forever Investments offers farmland fund sponsorship, wealth preservation strategies, sustainable asset management and long-term investment planning. Our guide on how to evaluate farmland before you buy covers due diligence more broadly. Learn more about us or request information.

This article is general educational information, not tax, legal or investment advice, and not an offer to sell or a solicitation to buy any security. Conservation easement rules are complex and fact-specific; consult a qualified tax advisor and attorney before granting, buying or selling any easement.

← More articles from Forever Investments